A British fashion retailer offering Black Friday bargain-hunters discounts of up to 99% faced criticism and questions on social media over how it could keep its promises to pay factory workers fairly when charging such low prices.
Manchester-based Pretty Little Thing and its parent company Boohoo Group Plc came under pressure from campaigner and media reports earlier this year over working conditions and low pay at garment factories in Leicester, central England.
In September, Boohoo accepted all the recommendations of an independent review that found several failings in its supply chain in England and set out steps to tackle the problems.
But social media users expressed outrage over the discount being offered by Pretty Little Thing for the Black Friday sale and said the promotion cast doubt on its commitment to safeguard workers’ rights.
“Pretty Little Thing selling literal clothes for 5p and still being able to make a profit isn’t funny, it’s a reminder that the industry constantly exploits Black, Indigenous, and People of Color through unacceptable pay and poor conditions,” wrote author and model Jamie Windust on Twitter.
Others said such prices showed a disregard for labour and environmental standards.
A Twitter user called @SezSew said that “56 items for £28 shouldn’t be possible if the human beings making them were paid a fair wage, and the fabrics used were of an environmentally sound quality.”
Another Twitter user, identified only as Becky, said Black Friday appeared “a race by some retailers to prove how unethical their clothes are”.
“I’d love to hear @OfficialPLT’s argument for selling clothing for literal pennies,” she wrote.
A spokesman for Pretty Little Thing declined to comment on the concerns raised on social media, saying the 99% discount was being offered on selected lines while stock lasts.
“After a bleak 2020 for most of us, we wanted to offer something competitive and understand people may be spending less in what is usually the festive shopping period,” the spokesman added.
Joanna Ewart-James, executive director of anti-human trafficking and modern slavery organisation Freedom United, said the company’s “extreme promo says everything about fast fashion”.
“Its priority is ensuring excessive consumption, not paying workers real wages,” she told the Thomson Reuters Foundation.
“The fact this comes on the back of a damning ‘independent’ review into parent company Boohoo is a kick in the teeth for workers,” she added in an emailed comment.
In July, British retailer Next Plc said it had removed branded items by Pretty Little Thing from its websites due to a report from workers’ rights group Labour Behind the Label.
Next, along with two other retailers, Zalando SE and Amazon.com Inc, said they had also decided to delist products made by Boohoo following a report in The Sunday Times that said workers making clothes for the company in Leicester were being paid as little as 3.50 pounds ($4.38) an hour.
Support Ethical Journalism. Support The Dispatch
The Dispatch is a sincere effort in ethical journalism. Truth, Accuracy, Independence, Fairness, Impartiality, Humanity and Accountability are key elements of our editorial policy. But we are still not able to generate great stories, because we don’t have adequate resources. As more and more media falls into corporate and political control, informed citizens across the world are funding independent journalism initiatives. Here is your chance to support your local media startup and help independent journalism survive. Click the link below to make a payment of your choice and be a stakeholder in public spirited journalism